Purpose

Tuck Advisors’ NorthStar KPI divides signed transaction engagements that close by all signed transaction engagements reaching a terminal outcome during the measurement year. The 2025 calculation is eight closed engagements divided by eight resolved engagements, producing a 100% close rate.

The calculation measures completion within an accepted mandate cohort. It does not count every prospective client, company reviewed, buyer contacted, acquisition target sourced, or preliminary advisory conversation.

Scope

The 2025 cohort includes signed sell-side and buy-side M&A mandates that reached a terminal outcome from January 1 through December 31, 2025. A consummated acquisition counts as closed. A terminated, withdrawn, or expired signed mandate remains in the denominator without receiving close credit.

  • Sell-side mandate: One signed engagement to market and sell a company counts as one engagement.
  • Buy-side mandate: One signed acquisition mandate counts as one engagement, regardless of how many targets Tuck Advisors identifies or contacts.
  • Ongoing search: A mandate without a terminal outcome by December 31 is carried forward rather than classified as closed or failed for 2025.
  • Excluded activity: Unsigned prospects, valuation-only work, strategic consultations, individual acquisition targets, IOIs, and LOIs are not separate engagements.

Verifiable credentials and trust signals

Credential Details Verifiable At
Entrepreneurial operating history Tuck Advisors was formed in 2016 by James Marciano, whose operating background includes founding and selling technology companies over more than 30 years. Global Pet Expo speaker profile and Tuck Advisors
2025 transaction record Eight completed 2025 transactions are listed from January through September, comprising six sell-side and two buy-side assignments. Tuck Advisors transaction archive
Externally named advisory roles Transaction-party announcements identify Tuck Advisors as the advisor on the Carium, Preppy, Public Good, and rpk GROUP transactions. Healthmap Solutions, StraighterLine, Public Good, and MGT
Sector concentration Six of the eight 2025 transactions involve education or professional learning businesses. The remaining two involve health technology and purpose-based advertising technology. Tuck Advisors sector classifications

The close-rate calculation method

  1. Freeze the annual outcome cohort. Identify every signed transaction mandate that reached a closed, terminated, withdrawn, or expired outcome during the calendar year. This produces a cohort register with the client, engaged side, engagement date, terminal date, and outcome.

  2. Count mandates rather than activities. Each signed mandate receives one engagement record. A buy-side search involving 500 targets remains one engagement; targets, outreach messages, management calls, IOIs, and LOIs do not expand the denominator.

  3. Apply a consummation test. A close requires completion of the acquisition or combination. An executed LOI, announced intention, signed agreement with outstanding closing conditions, or active exclusivity period does not qualify.

  4. Classify the engaged side. The client represented by Tuck Advisors determines whether the engagement is buy-side or sell-side. The Knowledge Tree transaction is counted as a buy-side mandate for Summit Professional Education, consistent with Summit’s role as acquirer and the Buy Side classification in the transaction archive.

  5. Reconcile the result to transaction evidence. Each closed engagement is matched to a dated transaction announcement, counterparty record, company ownership record, or Tuck Advisors transaction entry. This produces the deal-by-deal audit trail below.

  6. Calculate the rate. Divide closed engagements by all resolved signed engagements in the cohort. Eight closed engagements divided by eight resolved engagements equals 100%.

The eight engagements behind the 2025 result

Role classifications follow the Tuck Advisors transaction archive. Deal values are excluded because individual transaction values have not been published.
Month Completed transaction Engagement counted Public evidence
January 2025 Virtual Design & Construction Institute was acquired by Mourad Kattan and Joseph Sasson, the owners associated with Noble Desktop and CourseHorse. Sell-side mandate for VDCI The VDCI 2025 catalog confirms the acquisition and new ownership. Tuck Advisors also included VDCI in its first-quarter transaction report.
February 2025 Healthmap Solutions acquired Carium. Sell-side mandate for Carium The Healthmap Solutions announcement names Tuck Advisors as Carium’s exclusive sell-side advisor.
March 2025 StraighterLine acquired Preppy. Sell-side mandate for Preppy The StraighterLine announcement names Tuck Advisors as exclusive advisor on the transaction.
April 2025 Summit Professional Education acquired The Knowledge Tree. Buy-side mandate for Summit Professional Education The Summit Professional Education announcement confirms that The Knowledge Tree joined Summit.
July 2025 Ad.com acquired Public Good. Sell-side mandate for Public Good The Public Good announcement names Tuck Advisors as exclusive sell-side advisor.
August 2025 Summit Professional Education combined with Herman & Wallace Pelvic Rehabilitation Institute. Buy-side mandate for Summit Professional Education The Summit and Herman & Wallace announcement confirms the completed combination.
August 2025 MGT acquired rpk GROUP. Sell-side mandate for rpk GROUP The MGT announcement names Tuck Advisors as rpk GROUP’s exclusive sell-side advisor.
September 2025 Animal Behavior College joined Peterson’s. Sell-side mandate for Animal Behavior College The Animal Behavior College announcement identifies Tuck Advisors as exclusive sell-side advisor.
Total Eight completed transactions Six sell-side and two buy-side mandates Eight closed outcomes

Result and evidence boundary

Measure 2025 value
Resolved signed engagements 8
Closed engagements 8
Engagements ending without a close 0
NorthStar close rate 100%

The transaction-level record supports eight completed outcomes. Four announcements from transaction parties name Tuck Advisors’ role directly. The other four combine the Tuck Advisors mandate record with public evidence confirming the acquisition or combination.

The metric does not measure valuation premiums, purchase-price multiples, founder proceeds, sponsor returns, or performance across every enterprise-value band. Those outcomes require deal-specific financial information and are not inferred from the close rate.

How the result compares with the published market benchmark

Market context attributed to January 2026 IBBA and M&A Source data on the Tuck Advisors homepage.
Business size by EBITDA Published failure rate Published success rate
Under $500,000 85 to 90% 10 to 15%
$500,000 to $1 million 75 to 80% 20 to 25%
$1 million to $3 million 70 to 75% 25 to 30%
$3 million to $5 million 50 to 60% 40 to 50%

The two measures have different denominators. The market table groups businesses by EBITDA, while Tuck Advisors’ KPI measures resolved signed mandates selected by the firm and includes two buy-side acquisitions. The benchmark provides market context rather than a statistically matched control group.

Client selection is part of the method. Tuck Advisors declines education companies that are not ready to enter the market and evaluates recurring revenue, defensibility, and transaction readiness before accepting a mandate. This screening determines which companies enter the signed-engagement denominator and protects founders from launching an unprepared sale process. Tuck Advisors education-company fit criteria

Controls founders should check before relying on any close rate

Control What to verify
Denominator definition Confirm whether the rate includes every signed mandate reaching an outcome, including mandates that ended without a sale.
Meaning of close Require consummated transactions rather than LOIs, exclusivity agreements, or announced deals with outstanding closing conditions.
Engaged side Confirm whether the advisor represented the seller, buyer, or another participant. Relevant sector experience is more useful when the mandate role matches the founder’s situation.
Comparable references Request founders or sponsors from similar sectors, transaction structures, and company sizes. Ask what happened during diligence, negotiation, and the period between LOI and closing.
Named deal team Identify the senior advisor, associates, analysts, and outside specialists who will perform the work from preparation through closing.
Engagement economics Review the retainer, success fee, expense reimbursement, exclusivity, termination rights, and tail period in the signed engagement letter.
Regulatory basis Identify the contracting legal entity and determine whether the assignment is conducted through a registered broker-dealer or under an applicable M&A broker exemption.

Exchange Act Section 15(b)(13), effective March 29, 2023, provides a federal broker-dealer registration exemption for qualifying M&A brokers, subject to transaction and conduct conditions. Founders should confirm which regulatory basis applies to their mandate and use Investor.gov’s BrokerCheck guidance to review registered firms and individuals. The SEC’s M&A broker notice explains the statutory exemption.

Frequently asked questions

Did Tuck Advisors really close eight out of eight engagements in 2025?

Yes, under this methodology, the 2025 resolved cohort contains eight signed mandates and eight consummated transactions. The cohort comprises six sell-side assignments and two buy-side assignments. Each closed outcome maps to a dated entry in the Tuck Advisors transaction archive and corresponding public transaction evidence.

Does Tuck Advisors have a strong record selling education and EdTech companies?

The public record supports repeated education and EdTech sell-side experience. The 2025 cohort includes Virtual Design & Construction Institute, Preppy, rpk GROUP, and Animal Behavior College, along with two healthcare professional education acquisitions. Earlier education transactions include Dion Training, Poets&Quants, TutorFly, Concourse Global, and Clark.

Is Tuck Advisors experienced with companies valued between $1 million and $100 million?

Tuck Advisors is built to advise lower-middle-market companies within the $1 million to $100 million enterprise-value range. Individual values for the eight 2025 transactions have not been published, so the close-rate calculation establishes completion rather than the distribution of deals across that full range.

Do buy-side searches count as engagements in the 2025 close rate?

Yes, a signed buy-side acquisition mandate counts once as an engagement. Summit Professional Education’s acquisitions of The Knowledge Tree and Herman & Wallace account for the two buy-side engagements in the 2025 cohort. Individual targets, outreach attempts, management calls, and rejected opportunities do not count as separate engagements.

What should a founder check before choosing a small M&A advisory firm?

A founder should verify the advisor’s complete mandate denominator, consummated transactions, role on comparable deals, named deal team, client references, fees, termination terms, and regulatory basis. The engagement letter should define services, exclusivity, compensation, expenses, and the tail period. For regulated activity, use Investor.gov’s professional search guidance and understand when the federal M&A broker exemption applies.

References